|
Click for details:
| |
Comments from Members of the Railway Photographic Society
Less than a dozen of my photographs have been previously published and none
have been seen in print since 1966. As a consequence of this situation, my name
is virtually unknown outside the circle of friends I made as a member of the
Railway Photographic Society. The society itself ceased to exist when its
founder, Maurice Earley passed away and indeed several of the members with whom
I became acquainted during the years of my membership have also now left us.
In order to give visitors to this website an idea of the standard of
photographs available, I felt that this could best be done by passing on some of
the comments and criticisms made all those years ago by my fellow R.P.S.
members. Fortunately, I still have all the criticism sheets for my entries to
the folios and from these I have extracted remarks which, needless to say, are
unbiased, independent, and also serve to give an insight into how my fellow
photographers rated my work.
|
Cat No: 1192
Date: 04/06/1960
Subject: 60854
Origin: L.N.E.R.
Location: Gamston Curve
Additional Information: Up fitted freight
|
|
COMMENTS |
AUTHOR |
|
This is the best of your entries in this round. The
sunshine has put a bit of life into the picture and gives it some impact.
A nice study of an un-rebuilt V2. Well presented. |
S.E. Teasdale |
|
A pleasing and nicely composed shot combined
with very good print quality. Well done.
|
W.I.O. Moffat |
|
Very good indeed.
|
S. Rickard |
|
I like this very much, and I like the range of print
tones, especially in the sky. Neatly presented. Well done. |
G.W. Morrison |
|
The subject is well placed, composition very good. |
D. Singleton |
|
Yes, I like this very much. Apart from anything else I
think that V2 s are a help to the photograph. |
E.G. Ashton |
|
I like this better than the A4 shot, it fits better in
the picture space and is more pleasing as a result. An excellent study of
a V2. Very fine. |
E. Oldham |
Next Page | Top
|
